Thanks for the tips.

I've actually tried two different types of stripping from Home Depot. The first was D-shaped hollow. I liked it, but it was just too small in a couple areas. You could see daylight from the inside. A slightly bigger version might work, but I haven't found it.

Most recently, I tried the solid square type. I think it was 3/8 W x 1/4 T. It sealed great, but made it too hard to close the door. Leaving the door closed for a while to let it seat helped, but if the door was open more than 30 seconds, it grew back to normal.