Welcome to Club Hot Rod!  The premier site for everything to do with Hot Rod, Customs, Low Riders, Rat Rods, and more. 

  •  » Members from all over the US and the world!
  •  » Help from all over the world for your questions
  •  » Build logs for you and all members
  •  » Blogs
  •  » Image Gallery
  •  » Many thousands of members and hundreds of thousands of posts! 

YES! I want to register an account for free right now!  p.s.: For registered members this ad will NOT show

 
Like Tree20Likes

Thread: Aluminum vs Brass Radiator
          
   
   

Reply To Thread
Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 25
  1. #1
    Eliot Ness's Avatar
    Eliot Ness is offline CHR Member Visit my Photo Gallery
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Lexington
    Car Year, Make, Model: '40 Chevy Coupe, 350/TH400
    Posts
    29

    Aluminum vs Brass Radiator

     



    I have a 1940 Chevy coupe with a 350 SBC that has run hot for years. It has a Walker radiator that Walker repaired about 4 years ago so there is no stop leak in it. I have the biggest electric fan and shroud that Walker made and required a 50 amp relay. I have a 180 degree thermostat and on a cool day it runs right at 180 degrees on a VDO gauge with the sender mounted in the head.

    On a hot day it isn't unusual for me to run 210+ on the freeway and if I hit a traffic back-up I have to pull off the road, lift the hood and let the electric fan cool it off back to 180. I really would like it to run cooler in stop and go situations. I also have a Stewart high flow water pump and my lower radiator hose does have a spring.

    When Walker was in business they said brass cooled better while others said aluminum. I guess my question is has anyone went from a good brass radiator to an aluminum one and noticed a significance cooling advantage? I don't mind dropping the cash on a new aluminum radiator, but I'd hate to make that investment just to see no noticeable improvement.

    I should note that my electric fan evolution has went from a Spal with no shroud, to a Cooling Components (Walker) with a shroud, to my current Walker fan and and I haven't really noticed a lot of improvement from the first to the last. Attached (I hope) is a picture of my current radiator and fan.

    The only anomaly I can think of is my car has never had any inner fenders, which I think would allow more air circulation.

    Thanks in advance for any ideas.

    John

  2. #2
    shine's Avatar
    shine is offline CHR Member Visit my Photo Gallery
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    bluff dale texas
    Car Year, Make, Model: 47 inderweed
    Posts
    2,109

    210-215 is normal for a sbc in traffic. 200 down the highway is perfect with todays fuel . i use aluminum radiators and have for over 30 years. never had much luck with walker. i opted to have the orig recored instead.
    NTFDAY likes this.

  3. #3
    firebird77clone's Avatar
    firebird77clone is offline CHR Member Visit my Photo Gallery
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Location
    Hamilton
    Car Year, Make, Model: 69 nomad, 73 charger, 74 vega
    Posts
    3,900

    Add an oil cooler.
    .
    Education is expensive. Keep that in mind, and you'll never be terribly upset when a project goes awry.
    EG

  4. #4
    Hotrod46's Avatar
    Hotrod46 is offline CHR Member Visit my Photo Gallery
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Vidalia
    Car Year, Make, Model: 1946 Ford Coupe, 1962 Austin Healey 3000
    Posts
    1,496

    I have a 46 Ford coupe that is very similar to your 40 Chevy. When I bought the unfinished car, it came with a massive 4 core copper/brass radiator. Due to the engine being mounted a little too far forward, there was not much room for a large fan. The car ran hot from day one. The 383 stroker didn't help. It would run 190-200 on the highway and spike to 230+ before you could get off the road and to the pump at a gas stop. This constant overheating finally cooked the 383 and I had to replace it with a 350. I tried every fan and shroud combo I could fit (mechanical and electric) and nothing helped. I refused to believe the radiator was at fault, but finally decided to change it since that was the only option left.

    I swapped it for the largest aluminum Griffin Rat Rod series radiator I could get in. Has two 1 1/4" tubes. I also fitted a Cooling Components electric fan and shroud. This combo just barely fits. Fan has a super powerful motor that requires a 60+ amp relay if ran in single speed mode. The car finally runs decent temps. 180-185 on the highway with AC and 200 in traffic on a hot day. Still can't run the AC in traffic though.

    As I understand it, copper does conduct heat better than aluminum, but copper/brass radiators have to be soldered together with lead solder. The fins are soldered to the tubes during construction and the lead interface between them acts like an insulator. Aluminum radiators use various aluminum bonding processes to attach the fins to the tubes, so there is a more efficient heat path. Also, aluminum allows for larger tubes so there is effectively more water in contact with the tube wall.

    I do have to add that much of my problem is airflow related. With the engine too far forward, air has much harder time making it through the engine compartment. I have plans to correct this in the near future, as well as fit a larger cored radiator.
    Last edited by Hotrod46; 07-21-2022 at 08:22 PM.
    Mike

    I seldom do anything within the scope of logical reason and calculated cost/benefit, etc-
    I'm following my pass​ion

  5. #5
    johnboy is offline CHR Member Visit my Photo Gallery
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    Tataraimaka NZ
    Car Year, Make, Model: `47 Ford sedan, A.C.Cobra replica.
    Posts
    2,630

    We had that problem a while back, and we eventually got it pretty well sussed.
    This thread may be of some use to you:

    Bus is overheating.

    But...we finally got to the bottom of the problem with help from a fella many many years younger than I...It's a Chev 400 Vortec LS3 donkey, which was purchased as a crate motor, but had an LS1 card in it.
    So the computer was programmed to be sending the wrong messages out to the various components.
    To suss that is well out of my tiny knowledge of electronics.

    Good luck!
    Last edited by johnboy; 07-21-2022 at 09:58 PM.
    johnboy
    Mountain man. (Retired.)
    Some mistakes are too much fun to be made only once.
    I don't know everything about anything, and I don't know anything about lots of things.

    '47 Ford sedan. 350 -- 350, Jaguar irs + ifs.
    '49 Morris Minor. Datsun 1500cc, 5sp manual, Marina front axle, Nissan rear axle.
    '51 Ford school bus. Chev 400 ci Vortec 5 sp manual + Gearvendors 2sp, 2000 Chev lwb dually chassis and axles.
    '64 A.C. Cobra replica. Ford 429, C6 auto, Torana ifs, Jaguar irs.

  6. #6
    Mike P's Avatar
    Mike P is offline CHR Member Visit my Photo Gallery
    Join Date
    Mar 2003
    Location
    SW Arizona
    Car Year, Make, Model: 57 Ply, 68 Ply Valiant, 83 El Camino
    Posts
    3,747

    “…….210-215 is normal for a sbc in traffic. 200 down the highway is perfect with todays fuel ……”

    I agree with shine that the temperature is not out of line. I would add that if you haven’t already, the first step it to verify the temperature gauge is reading accurately. The easiest way is to use a temperature gun and compare the readings. There not really all that expensive and are a good investment anyway. I normally like to measure the temperature as it comes thru the thermostat housing.

    As you and Mike both mentioned I have the same understanding that brass/copper does transfer heat more efficiently than aluminum. The aluminum however allows for a more efficient tube design than brass. When you compare the tube size in a brass radiator to an aluminum one you will find that the aluminum tubes are usually a good deal wider than the brass tubes. The reason for this is that after a certain size the brass tubes are more likely to crack over time due to expansion and contraction. As the aluminum tubes can be made wider they expose more surface area to the air and the radiator itself is more efficient than a brass one.

    That being said there are a few things to look for when choosing an aluminum radiator. The main thing is tube size and tube count. On brass radiators then you wanted a more efficient radiator you would look for one with more rows of tubes (i.e. going to a 3 or 4 row radiator). Now normally the tubes were smaller in a 4 row than a 3 row but the total amount of surface area was increased so the radiator was more efficient.

    On an aluminum radiator look for one that will give you the largest amount of tube surface area, not the highest tube count. I normally go for a radiator with either 2 rows of 1” inch tubes or three rows of ¾” tubes.

    A lot of times if you buying on-line, the cheaper radiators will list the row count but not give you tube size. I usually avoid these because when you get the radiator you will often find that you get a 2 row with ¾” tubes or a 3 row with ½” tubes.

    After one experience with 4 row aluminum radiators, I avoid them like the plague. Back when I was in my El Camino phase I had ordered a 4 row with ½” tubes to the El Camino I built for my wife. When the car was done I drove it to Tucson AZ (about 75 miles away) on a 100+ degree day. On the interstate it was running about 220 degrees…..a little warmer than I like. I had new radiator I had picked up for another El Camino I was building that was a 2 row with1” tubes so I changes the radiators out. Technically I had the same amount of tube surface area on the 2 radiators, but the 2 row ran 10 degrees cooler when I duplicated the trip a few days later. I read a few different theories over the years why the 4 row radiators are less efficient, but who knows.


    Basically for me I have found that a well designed aluminum radiator works better than a brass copper one. If I have any complaints, it’s that on some cars, to my eye, a shiny aluminum radiator can look out of place (lately I’ve tended to go for a nostalgia look). Although it’s generally not recommended, I’ve never had a problem using a light coat of black paint on an aluminum radiator to make it blend in a little better.


    Anyway that’s my 2 cents.



    .
    I've NEVER seen a car come from the factory that couldn't be improved.....

  7. #7
    shine's Avatar
    shine is offline CHR Member Visit my Photo Gallery
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    bluff dale texas
    Car Year, Make, Model: 47 inderweed
    Posts
    2,109

    years ago my radiator guy told me that the reason my walker radiator ran hot was it was too thick. he recored my stock 47 ford radiator with a thin 3 row zcore. worked like a champ. he said that wrecker guys would come in and want bigger thicker radiators so they wouldn't overheat setting around. he would set them up with a 3 row and then not tell them. he loved it when they would bring in another one for that thicker core. the look on their face was priceless.
    it's about air flow , not number of tubes. brass/copper goes out the window once you cover them in black paint. i prefer cross flow aluminum over anything else.

  8. #8
    shine's Avatar
    shine is offline CHR Member Visit my Photo Gallery
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    bluff dale texas
    Car Year, Make, Model: 47 inderweed
    Posts
    2,109

    one more thing. you must have 1/2 in or more between your ac condenser and radiator. that's what was wrong with walkers .
    TooMany2count likes this.

  9. #9
    jerry clayton's Avatar
    jerry clayton is offline CHR Member Visit my Photo Gallery
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    Bartlett
    Posts
    6,831

    The fan blade rotation speed on the electric fans can be a problem-----If the fan is not powered it will rotate at a rpm that effectively is sorta like an airplane propeller on a engine out situation---and it basicly takes up the drag coefiecant of a complete circle---so it really becomes an solid disc? BLOCKING the flow of air---
    If your fan is in front of the rad, this is happening all the time----

    Looking at the pic of your radiator the amount of airflow thru that is really limited by the amount of visable fin that you can see between the blades----------
    Last edited by jerry clayton; 07-22-2022 at 06:55 AM.
    NTFDAY and glennsexton like this.
    By popular opinions-just a grumpy old man key board bully--But really, if you are going to ask for help on an internet site, at least answer questions about what you are asking about-----

  10. #10
    firebird77clone's Avatar
    firebird77clone is offline CHR Member Visit my Photo Gallery
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Location
    Hamilton
    Car Year, Make, Model: 69 nomad, 73 charger, 74 vega
    Posts
    3,900

    Ok I'm posting this again, because it received no feedback. Add an oil cooler.
    .
    Education is expensive. Keep that in mind, and you'll never be terribly upset when a project goes awry.
    EG

  11. #11
    rspears's Avatar
    rspears is offline CHR Member/Contributor Visit my Photo Gallery
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Location
    Gardner, KS
    Car Year, Make, Model: '33 HiBoy Coupe, '32 HiBoy Roadster
    Posts
    10,989

    Quote Originally Posted by firebird77clone View Post
    Ok I'm posting this again, because it received no feedback. Add an oil cooler.
    For a street car I don't see that an oil cooler makes any sense. Extra capacity (added cost at every oil change), increased failure points, and little if any benefit. The temperature of the oil, contained in the pan, does little to nothing to affect the coolant temperature which is much more dynamic. External oil coolers are for track cars that operate at sustained high RPM's, and perhaps for tow vehicles pushing the limits on tow capacity. Other than that they are a liability.
    Concentrate on getting the coolant flow right and controlling the air flow through the radiator and you'll solve your problem.
    Roger
    Enjoy the little things in life, and you may look back one day and realize that they were really the BIG things.

  12. #12
    firebird77clone's Avatar
    firebird77clone is offline CHR Member Visit my Photo Gallery
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Location
    Hamilton
    Car Year, Make, Model: 69 nomad, 73 charger, 74 vega
    Posts
    3,900

    thanks for the feedback on the oil cooler.

    I'm not sure we see eye - to-eye on this, let me throw my perspective your way, let me know if it makes sense.

    Sometimes a cooling system is simply not sufficient. Whether this is insufficient air flow, radiator surface, flow rate or combination is a different discussion. Not enough heat is being removed.

    Consider for a moment that the oil is just as capable of moving heat as the water.

    SO, if the cooling system isn't removing enough heat, then provide a second path.

    By cooling the oil, you are removing additional heat. It's not about reducing the temperature of the oil pan.

    It's like turning the heater on full, you increase the cooling capacity by whatever the heater core will move. (You'll sweat, but the engine will drop a few degrees). Only in this case, the additional heat isn't blowing into the cab.

    And, cooling the oil has a distinct benefit to the viscosity.

    Anyway, beyond an additional failure point, did I change your perspective?

    Thanks for your input.
    Last edited by firebird77clone; 07-23-2022 at 07:47 PM.
    .
    Education is expensive. Keep that in mind, and you'll never be terribly upset when a project goes awry.
    EG

  13. #13
    34_40's Avatar
    34_40 is offline CHR Member Visit my Photo Gallery
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Location
    New Bedford
    Car Year, Make, Model: 34 Ford 3W Coupe Replica
    Posts
    14,606

    I doubt you'll change anyone's mind and for a variety of reasons. Actually I think you are both right. If the cooling system is configured correctly - adding an oil cooler becomes redundant, and adding an oil cooler as a band-aid will present other headaches such as squeezing more components in an already tight engine bay.. where will you place this cooler? In front of the radiator?? That doesn't seem logical does it? Again, I don't think you're wrong but maybe they go through all that work and expense and still overheat in traffic or sitting downtown... You're still faced with the cooling system isn't correct. And from my memory, the whole number of rows was maxed at 4 and proved to be awful.. to many rows prevented the air from flowing. So then it was the tube size. There needed to be enough flow of coolant being exposed to the tube surface to get max cooling. For quite a long time the honeycomb type was head and shoulders above... except for so many points of failure! LOL.
    Dave Severson likes this.

  14. #14
    rspears's Avatar
    rspears is offline CHR Member/Contributor Visit my Photo Gallery
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Location
    Gardner, KS
    Car Year, Make, Model: '33 HiBoy Coupe, '32 HiBoy Roadster
    Posts
    10,989

    Quote Originally Posted by firebird77clone View Post
    Anyway, beyond an additional failure point, did I change your perspective?
    Nope. Fix the coolant problem.
    Roger
    Enjoy the little things in life, and you may look back one day and realize that they were really the BIG things.

  15. #15
    firebird77clone's Avatar
    firebird77clone is offline CHR Member Visit my Photo Gallery
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Location
    Hamilton
    Car Year, Make, Model: 69 nomad, 73 charger, 74 vega
    Posts
    3,900

    Thx guys. Good discussion.
    .
    Education is expensive. Keep that in mind, and you'll never be terribly upset when a project goes awry.
    EG

Reply To Thread
Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
Links monetized by VigLink