Thanks Dan
Turns out I'm relieved the first one didn't work out. This one that we bought yesterday is like new. I wish I had a picture of my wife driving it, the grin on her face was priceless!
Here are a few shots below. Maybe when these current tires wear out I'll get a recommendation for new ones from you, these are Bridgestone's, not my favorite. Unfortunately Michelin doesn't seem to make an all season or any tire for that matter that fits both the front and back! I think Yokohama does, but don't know much about them.