Those are tough to call. Most of that repop tin comes from one source that's hard for we consumers to identify. As a generalization most of the vendors sell the ones that don't fit worth a damn without considerable reworking. Not only doesn't the "pad" that attaches at the crossbar not line up (I had one that the hole was 1/2" off, but the curve of the portion that flairs out to the fender isn't sufficient to reach the fender, about an inch short of the job. If you've got patience and drive, look for a set of originals. A set just showed up on ebay yesterday with a starting price of $150ish.