Roger that is exactly it. New shims weren't bad, just the cost of shipping was hard to eat. I figure I'm glad I did it on a cheap part vs. something really expensive. Just a part of the learning curve, I figured if I post this someone down the line might be spared a similar mistake.
Pat thanks for the generous offer! I would take you up on it, but have already ordered the new shims a couple of days ago.
Charley I actually thought of that but haven't welded cast iron before, and figured it would be more trouble than the 23 bucks for a new pair! :) I'm still thinking they will come in handy for something down the line! :)