If you want some really good judging sheets, more objective then most of them, get an ISCA sheet and use it. As Bob said, Judging is a tough job.... The majority of people don't have a clue what the criteria is and whoever wins there's at least 10 people in your face about it..... Best thing to do if you're part of a club running a show is give each participant a copy of the judging sheet when they come in so when they come up whining later it's easy to point out the errors of their logic!!!!! I've built a few show only cars and the level of detail involved with building a car that will be competitive in the big time shows requires about 40% more in labor hours.... I've won a lot of trophies, but the only one's I ever keep are the "people's choice" trophies, IMO they mean the most. The others have all been given to parts stores I buy from, or sometimes the first little kid that comes by and sez "Wow, neat car Mr."!!!!!!