Apologies and restraint

[36 sedan]

Let me start by simply saying I'm sorry.

Normally I practice a little more restraint, unfortunately recently I let my temper defuse my restraint. I'll try not to let it happen again.

[MelloYello]

We're all human, my friend, but it takes a man to apologize.

Em

[prpmmp]

Gibbs Rule # 6! Never Apologize its a sign of weakness Pete (Yea I watch to much TV(Boob Tube)

[glennsexton]

Let me start by simply saying I'm sorry.

Normally I practice a little more restraint, unfortunately recently I let my temper defuse my restraint. I'll try not to let it happen again.

You're a class act my friend

BTW, I have a couple high horsepower degrees and I've heard it all from those who think they know everything, "...Piled higher and Deeper...", "Please hire. Desperate", "Pizza hut Driver", etc., etc., etc... My favorite is when a young engineer wanna be starts a conversation, "Well I've been doing this for five years now..." I laugh on the inside and restrain myself as I typically have socks older then they are.

In the end, I don't necessarily want to be the smartest guy in the room, I hope to be the wisest and try real hard to remember to talk less and listen more. Proverbs 17:28 says, "Even fools are thought wise if they keep silent, and discerning if they hold their tongues."


I appreciate the passion of the people who regularly participate and I've given myself a couple "time-outs" over the years. There is still no car site I go to more often nor people that I enjoy more than CHR!

Regards All,
Glenn

[firebird77clone]

Glenn...

Buy some new socks.

[Whiplash23T]

At the end of the day, I believe you had " Everybodies Safety " at heart so really no apology necessary. What this site and 99 % of the members are about is building vehicles that are safe to been driven across town or across country with no risk of harm to fellow people or themselves. If you saw a weld on my car that you weren't happy about, I would expect you all to point it out before it became a major issue thanks and especially when it is a structural part of the car.

[firebird77clone]

[rspears]

Let me start by simply saying I'm sorry.

Normally I practice a little more restraint, unfortunately recently I let my temper defuse my restraint. I'll try not to let it happen again.

You have nothing to apologize for, and no reason to be sorry.

[glennsexton]

Glenn...

Buy some new socks.

Too Funny!!

[daveS53]

I think there's a lot to apologize for simply because it's IMPOSSIBLE to judge the structural integrity of a weld from a photo taken from a significant distance away. Anyone who doesn't understand that doesn't know much about welding, regardless of what claims they make. A whole lot of the MIG welds done on my frame by Oze look a lot worse than anything I've done.

That extended tirade was entirely made up from the poster(s) imaginations. Several members decided to jump on the band wagon and join the bashing with no evidence of any problem, other than the unsubstantiated allegations posted by 36 sedan. I'd be embarrassed to have been part of the bashing.

As I noted, I've been welding for over 40 years and never had a problem with anything I've welded. I've even done production stick welding, but of course I have no way to prove that.

Suddenly I get accused of not knowing what I'm doing and also lying about being a mechanical engineer, in addition to my alleged poor welding abilities. I'm not going to waste my time with a forum that's dominated by a small group of bitter old men who act as cyber bullies and hide behind claims of "protecting public safety" to justify the bullying.

When bicycling was my main hobby (for 25 years), I made over 20,000 posts on several different cycling websites and never had a problem like this. Some of these forums had fairly strict moderation and members could be banned for tirades like the one made 36 sedan.

[36 sedan]

Dave,
Please keep in mind I first started with a concern of safety and suggested you check your equipment adjustments and technic. The arguments and justification of your welds were not my comments, go back through the posts to confirm. I saw genuine concerns and suggested a safety issue, your pictures showed signs of weld undercut, too much heat in front of the weld and concave porous fill. All classic weld/technic problems, I then suggested a weld test. Your idea of a test consisting of jumping up and down on the frame may have been in humor, unfortunately I had no way of knowing you had such dry humor. The thought of someone being harmed (including you) irked my ire.
http://www.esabna.com/us/en/educatio...g-of-welds.cfm
As an engineer you know this. You also know the importance of safety and safe practices. For you and the public. I'll re-iterate I was genuine in my concern for your safety. If the pictures were poor (which I asked in my first concern), you could have simply posted better pictures. Or you could have said, thank you for your concerns I'll look into it and this would not have escalated.
Nuf said, I'll practice restraint...
Apologies for any insults towards education, not my intent.

[daveS53]

36 sedan:

I know a decent weld when I see it and I make acceptable welds. You've never posted anything that makes me think your opinion is more valuable than mine. Are you a professional welder?

As an engineer, I also know the huge amount of force it takes to break, even a small piece of bar stock, or that same piece of stock, adequately butt welded together. In the case of the 1/8" x 1 " stock, it's area is .125 square inches. If the steel has a tensile strength of 60,000 psi, it should resist a force of 7500 lbs. With that in mind, applying a force of only around 1000 lbs to it was a trivial test, but if the welding I did was really poor, it might have broken it apart.

In the real world, structures are designed with a safety factor that is many times the actual load. That's why those shock mounting ears are made of 3/16" x 2" steel and there's about 8 inches of weld length all around them. That creates a large safety factor. You'd have to make some really pititful welds for a bracket like I made to fail. Here's some information of safety factor.

https://www.engineersedge.com/analys...ety-review.htm

As I see it, there are a number of forum members who dislike me and take every opportunity to made rude remarks. If that makes you feel good, have at it, but you'll have to use someone else as your punching bag.

[jerry clayton]

Seems strange that over the years-----------engineers main purpose on a project seems to be production speed, and working to a standard that equates to an acceptable failure rate of the finished components--------except in the nucleur world

[stovens]

This thread started out as an apology. Either accept it or move on. An olive branch was presented, not much more to say!

[36 sedan]

Practicing restraint...