I'm an idiot...it was actually a coolant leak. I pulled out the stud and coolant came pouring out. It smells like the kid put the brown gooey permatex on the stud threads. I drained everything and resealed the threads with the ARP pst sealant. I hope that cures it otherwise I'll have to pull the heads and reseal all the studs. When looking at the new head gasket they all have a blue seal imprinted on all the bolt circles except for the bolt hole that is leaking. It makes sense now . Crossing my fingers.