more like the second one, but instead of the halo, which welds at the back and bends around the front, it has the front uprights come up, bend back and tie into the back hoop. and I think only one crosspiece in the front. I need to go take another look and take more pics and draw it somehow. I can't imagine somebody taking the time to do it and not doing it right, it's quite a lot of work they put in.

Red